Some Times You Learn The Lesson The Hard Way . . .

Recently the State of New Mexico passed HB0272 which is the New Mexico Transportation Network Company Services Act. It goes into effect July 1, 2015 and is proof that the Drivers needed a Representative in the making of these regulations. The thing most required by regulation of the Ride-Hail Services is restrictions on how the Ride-Hail Services are allowed to change the rates earned by Drivers. There are not many occupations where you can make a dollar one day and 25 cents the next and nobody give a damn how severe the impact upon your ability to pay your rent, feed your family, or even keep your car running. But, Ride-Hail Services are all under the impression that these are not important factors in how they conduct day to day business today.

2015 has become a very stressful year for the Ride-Hail Drivers as Uber has reduced Rider fares to such a degree that Drivers are on the verge of financial crisis with no relief in sight. Anybody that got suckered into the Uber Auto Purchase Program will likely have to file bankruptcy and give up on being a Small Business as the payments on the cars purchased preclude being able to afford food after the day is done. Most all the other drivers may survive but it is likely none will actually take home minimum wage.

Uber tells the media that drivers are making anywhere from $20.00 to $45.00 per hour as though the drivers are part of the affluent when in reality Uber has reduced the driver earnings to a fraction of what they used to be and increased Uber’s income while doing so.  As Independent Contractors are not protected by most of the labor laws, the regulation of earnings for the drivers does not exist leaving the Driver exposed to the risks of losing everything at any time due to act of the Ride-Hail Services. Minimum Wage Laws do not protect the Independent Contractor and by labeling the Drivers as Independent Contractors Uber is able to push all responsibilities of expense, insurance, and taxation onto the Drivers which are not being paid adequately to carry the burden.

Taxation is a good example. Because the drivers are Independent Contractors, Uber does not have to withhold or pay taxes on the contractors income. Employers pay a portion of the taxes, social security, and workman’s comp for regular employees. Independent Contractors are considered “self employed” or a “business” which means that the Independent Contractor has to pay both the Employers obligation and the employees obligation to taxes and the other standard payroll deductibles. Thus, the Independent Contractor is required to pay approximately 25% of his income to taxation.

In Uber’s opinion, you already had a car and a car loan before working with Uber, you will still have that obligation after working with Uber, so the costs of the car are not a factor when calculating the drivers income. Sounds like a 12 year old kid trying to justify not having to get a job and pay for his own obligations, doesn’t it. So to Uber, the fact that you are beating your car to death racing around City streets and to an early end of it’s life expectancy, is irrelevant as your car would be your car with or without your working with Uber.

Travis Kalanick said come run your own small business, be your own boss, you can make 5k per month working full time in San Francisco, and we will even help you buy a new car has proven to be little more than a trap to entice workers to join Uber’s workforce. Uber never said that the offer ends right after you commit to taking the job, And, Uber never even suggested that they were going to pull the rug out from beneath you repeatedly without concern for the impact on your family and your own obligations. To thwart driver’s claims of losses Uber has created “Guarantees” which are nothing more than a shell game, in which drivers have to work the hours, pick up the amount of riders, and other criteria making the driver eligible to be paid the amount of Ubers choosing regardless the amount the driver earns less.

How this works is Uber will guarantee the driver make $35.00 per hour if the driver works between the hours Uber requires, is on line in the app so much time per hour, makes at least one or more rider trips per hour, and has a 98% acceptance rate while working. However, not meeting every bit of the guarantee requirements allows Uber to rescind the guarantee. Doesn’t this type of control by an employer make the Independent Contractor an employee protected by the Fair Labor Standards Act and Uber obligated to compensate the driver as though an employee?

Anyway, back to the  New Mexico Transportation Network Company Services Act on it’s way to being the rule for TNC Services in New Mexico. The New Mexico Transportation Network Company Services Act goes so far as to say that drivers are not allowed to collect CASH TIPS from riders, which means that Uber will never allow tips to provide an increase to the driver’s income. Instead Uber will add an average increase to driver the calculated anticipated driver income and use the increased income as the ability to reduce rider rates further in the future. The New Mexico Transportation Network Company Services Act and all similar documents should have required a Representative from the Drivers be part of the process and the requirement of setting the rates to be charged at a level that provides for fairness to the Rider, the Driver, and the Ride-Hail  Services, limiting the amount of pay to the driver to at least minimum wage or higher as necessary for obligations such as expenses for the car and taxation. The negligence demonstrated by both Government and the Ride-Hail Services will likely have to be considered by the Courts in the near future. Until such time the jobs of 162,000 or more Drivers that once had worked worthwhile jobs created by Uber, will remain worthless jobs created by Uber.

As Independent Contractors, Drivers cannot unionize. But, they can join and be represented by a Professional Association in matters such as regulations and compensation. To provide this representation, the US Ride-Hail Driver’s Association is being formed but it is taking time to acquire membership as it is difficult to get the word out to all of the drivers with the limited funds the drivers have to invest into the development of the association with their current incomes barely adequate to cover their expenses to work.


6 thoughts on “Some Times You Learn The Lesson The Hard Way . . .

  1. I sent a letter to the New Mexico PRC stating all of this in great detail and got a call from an attorney from the National Labor Relations board. The only way rates are considered by the PRC is as it relates to the calculating of rates properly/consitantly for the rider. These are very valid issues and he said are ripe for pursuit via the States Attorney General, the Labor Board and Department of taxation revenue.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Gentlemen CREDIBILITY IS EVERYTHING…and misstatements as above will be an immediate turn of to those you seek to influence….THE New Mexico Law DID NT PROHIBIT TIPS….it PROHIBITED CASH TRANSACTIONS….in other words this was thought to be a way to prevent TNC Drivers from scalping “street hails” ….PLEASE if you are serious, then you need to refrain from mis-statements of fact!


    • I am sorry Patrick but I do not believe this requirement that we not be able to receive cash from riders has anything to do with Street Hails. Uber lied and said the tip was included to keep the rates low to attract riders. If the low rates required additional money from the rider, the rider would associate the costs as higher. If Uber requires we only accept the rider’s card through Ubers app, Uber will find a way to reduce drivers rates because of it, and take 20% while doing so. How many Uber drivers do you believe are out there picking up street hails? Have any drivers been fired or received tickets for picking up street hails? I really do not believe we have a significant street hail situation. But, in all fairness I can concede street hails as a possibility and the same for it being a concern for Uber. The same wording is in the Senate Bill for Utah, you will note my discussion of SB0294 does not say that tips are prohibited, but taking cash is. I thank you for your input and the need for my clarification. In addition, I thank you for your input as you have taken a well thought out approach to commenting where many do anything more than create spam rather than intelligent response to topics. Please continue to comment anytime you wish. If for no other reason but to keep me honest as such has always been my intent.

      Thank You,



Your Comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s